I’m a very big fan of the film Who Framed Roger Rabbit. It’s one of the greatest movies of all time in my book – the visual effects are astounding, even to this day, and it has a love for classic animation and old-time Hollywood that makes it a real pleasure to watch. It also brought characters like Bugs Bunny and Mickey Mouse to the screen together for the first time. And in the midst of all this, the movie manages to be a legitimate mystery with a solid, satisfactory ending. And so I finally decided to acquaint myself with the book that inspired the film version, Who Censored Roger Rabbit? by Gary K. Wolf.
Naturally, because I love the film as much as I do, the book would have a tough act to follow. But I decided to keep an open mind and try to enjoy the ride. Like the movie, the book stars Eddie Valiant, a hardboiled, cynical P.I. He is hired by Roger Rabbit to investigate the DeGreasy brothers. They are the heads of a large cartoon syndicate and have Roger under contract, playing second fiddle to one Baby Herman. But when he signed the contract, Roger was promised his own strip. The DeGreasys now deny ever offering him his own strip and refuse to let him go or sell him off to another syndicate, despite the interest shown in his talents.
Unfortunately – and it breaks my heart to say this – the book is nowhere near as good as the movie adaptation. There are so many problems with the book already, but when you get to the ending all bets are called off. Quite simply put this is the stupidest ending to any mystery I’ve ever read - and yes, I'm including The Act of Roger Murgatroyd when I say this. The author tries to play fair... by never explaining the rules of the game to you. In the last possible moment he pulls an explanation from his rear end: you’ve never had any indication whatsoever that this kind of solution is possible in this universe. So when the ending comes, it comes as a grade-A cheat of stunningly stupid proportions. If I described the ending to you right now, you’d be convinced I was cracking a joke about the book – that’s how bad it is.
Apart from the ending, something about the book constantly seemed off. And then it hit me about half-way through. Eddie Valiant was not a tough P.I., he was trying to be a tough P.I. Something about the language he used was just unconvincing. I couldn’t quite put my finger on it, but he seemed to be spouting one too many wisecracks and trying to play the tough guy in situations that didn’t call for it because that’s how P.I.s are supposed to act, right? Say what you like about Mike Hammer (don’t mind if I do), he was a genuinely tough character and you never doubted it for a second. Eddie just seems to be trying too hard and is unconvincing.
So overall I cannot recommend this book, especially if you’ve seen and enjoyed the movie. If you love that version, the book does things that are absolutely unforgiveable with the characters. It could even change the way you see the movie in the future, but not in a good way. I’m afraid I really can’t say anything in the book’s favour: I might have given it a cautious recommendation if it hadn’t done that idiotic twist, but that’s what really slammed the final nail into the coffin.
I worked for a book store in the early 80s when this book came out, and read a couple of chapters (at most) before giving up on it. However, I did enjoy the movie, even if I don't love it as much as you do.ReplyDelete
Barry, I don't blame you. It wasn't the best-written book I've ever read and the social commentary was pretty bland, obvious and predictable. At the very least you didn't have to suffer through to the ending.Delete
I am so glad to hear someone agree with me. I just couldn't get through the book and didn't want to see the film. Now maybe I will change my mind about the film. Thanks, DeeReplyDelete
I hope you enjoy the film if you get around to seeing it. It's completely different from the book in all the good ways, and Bob Hoskins' outstanding performance makes it a truly special film. Oh, and the music is just grand! It does a great job of emulating music from the film noir that I have seen.Delete
Big fan of the movie and I had heard that the book was quite different. Shame it's scuh a crashing disappointment - I guess it's a classic case of great concept, shame about the execution (sic). And by the way, great to have you back in the blogosphere - I was starting to think we'd have to hire an inquiry agent!ReplyDelete
Well, I was never *gone*, per se, but I was very busy. My parents went on another roadtrip so I decided to do some more renovation work. I painted the kitchen, the bathroom, etc. and also did a backsplash in the kitchen. (Then I went and smashed a hole into the drywall when I nearly fell off the stairs due to my own stupidity, and I had to patch that up.) While all that was going on, I bought a new computer and have been really, really slowly transferring my files and programs there. I don't think I'm even 30% through with that process. So yeah, I've just been really, really busy. There are a bunch of books that I haven't reviewed yet but I've gotta give it a shot in the near future.Delete
I have never seen the movie, though from what you have said I really should track it down. I agree with Sergio (bloodymurder) - it's great to have you back in the blogosphere. It's a lot of fun to read this blog.ReplyDelete
Glad you like this little corner of the internet. For the sake of my sanity I can't afford to go down to the west side very often, but I try my best to inform and maybe entertain just a little along the way.Delete
Oh, and do try to see the movie. I just got a Blu-Ray copy and although the picture quality was excellent, the bonus features (which are worth watching to see how they pulled off the technical wizardry of the movie) seem identical to the standard ones you'd find on any DVD.
I'm a fan of the movie, and I bought the book as a result. I didn't have a problem with the ending, but overall the book isn't that great. I did buy the Kindle version only because I felt that Gary K. Wolf deserved at least some thanks for writing a book that inspired one of my favourite films of all time.ReplyDelete
If you want to read something that actually succeeds where Wolf fails---in other words, doing to the syndicated newspaper comic strips what Who Framed Roger Rabbit? did for Golden Age Hollywood cartoon shorts---find yourself a copy of Weapon Brown by Jason Yungbluth. It's an on-line comic that will eventually be printed out as a hard copy. I won't provide a link because I don't want to be accused of spamming, but if you see it you'll know what I'm talking about.